Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.

This dissertation explores theoretical and empirical aspects of the relation between supervision and project performance. I focus on development projects funded by the World Bank and on supervision done by the World Bank. The World Bank is the preeminent international development organization both in terms of money lent and leadership; furthermore, data measuring project performance and supervision are relative comprehensive. The link between supervision and performance is of theoretical interest because it illuminates one side of World Bank-borrower interaction and of practical interest because supervision is an instrument controlled by the World Bank which may improve project performance. Chapter One compares an adversarial view of World Bank-borrower relations with a cooperative view. The adversarial view leads to a principal-agent model where a portion of implementation problems arise because World Bank information about borrower actions is incomplete. The importance of information links the monitoring component of World Bank supervision to project performance. In contrast, asymmetric information plays no role in the cooperative view; implementation problems are purely technical and hence the role of World Bank supervision is less clear. The chapter outlines the different empirical predictions of the two views and highlights policy implications for the design and supervision of development projects. Chapter Two is an empirical study of supervision and performance which addresses issues raised in Chapter One. Data are from 1426 World Bank-funded projects completed between 1981 and 1991. Analysis of the influence of World Bank supervision on project performance uses annual supervision and annual interim performance ratings. The annual updating process which generates the discrete interim ratings is described by an ordered probit likelihood function. Maximum likelihood estimates indicate a positive though small impact of supervision on performance. However, if there is a significant and persistent increase in the level of supervision, a gain of several percentage points in the economic rate of return is predicted. Supervision is more effective early in project implementation and in projects which smaller loans. The impact of supervision appears to be primarily due to the monitoring component rather than the assistance component; however, data limitations preclude a formal test.

Main Author: Kilby, Christopher.
Format: Villanova Faculty Authorship
Language: English
Published: 2000
Online Access: http://ezproxy.villanova.edu/login?url=https://digital.library.villanova.edu/Item/vudl:177692
PID vudl:177692
id vudl:177692
modeltype_str_mv vudl-system:CoreModel
vudl-system:CollectionModel
vudl-system:ResourceCollection
datastream_str_mv DC
PARENT-QUERY
PARENT-LIST-RAW
PARENT-LIST
MEMBER-QUERY
MEMBER-LIST-RAW
LICENSE
AGENTS
PROCESS-MD
RELS-EXT
hierarchytype
sequence_vudl_177661_str 0000000011
has_order_str no
hierarchy_top_id vudl:641262
hierarchy_top_title Villanova faculty author
hierarchy_parent_id vudl:177661
hierarchy_parent_title Kilby Christopher
hierarchy_sequence 0000000011
hierarchy_first_parent_id_str vudl:177692
hierarchy_sequence_sort_str 0000000011
hierarchy_all_parents_str_mv vudl:172968
vudl:641262
vudl:177661
first_indexed 2014-01-11T22:09:49Z
last_indexed 2021-04-12T19:56:50Z
recordtype vudl
fullrecord <root> <url> http://digital.library.villanova.edu/files/vudl:177692/DC </url> <thumbnail> http://digital.library.villanova.edu/files/vudl:177692/THUMBNAIL </thumbnail> </root>
spelling
institution Villanova University
collection Digital Library
language English
dc_source_str_mv Dissertation.
author Kilby, Christopher.
author_facet_str_mv Kilby, Christopher.
author_or_contributor_facet_str_mv Kilby, Christopher.
author_s Kilby, Christopher.
spellingShingle Kilby, Christopher.
Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
author-letter Kilby, Christopher.
author_sort_str Kilby, Christopher.
dc_title_str Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
title Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
title_short Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
title_full Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
title_fullStr Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
title_full_unstemmed Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
collection_title_sort_str supervision and performance: the case of world bank projects.
title_sort supervision and performance: the case of world bank projects.
format Villanova Faculty Authorship
description This dissertation explores theoretical and empirical aspects of the relation between supervision and project performance. I focus on development projects funded by the World Bank and on supervision done by the World Bank. The World Bank is the preeminent international development organization both in terms of money lent and leadership; furthermore, data measuring project performance and supervision are relative comprehensive. The link between supervision and performance is of theoretical interest because it illuminates one side of World Bank-borrower interaction and of practical interest because supervision is an instrument controlled by the World Bank which may improve project performance. Chapter One compares an adversarial view of World Bank-borrower relations with a cooperative view. The adversarial view leads to a principal-agent model where a portion of implementation problems arise because World Bank information about borrower actions is incomplete. The importance of information links the monitoring component of World Bank supervision to project performance. In contrast, asymmetric information plays no role in the cooperative view; implementation problems are purely technical and hence the role of World Bank supervision is less clear. The chapter outlines the different empirical predictions of the two views and highlights policy implications for the design and supervision of development projects. Chapter Two is an empirical study of supervision and performance which addresses issues raised in Chapter One. Data are from 1426 World Bank-funded projects completed between 1981 and 1991. Analysis of the influence of World Bank supervision on project performance uses annual supervision and annual interim performance ratings. The annual updating process which generates the discrete interim ratings is described by an ordered probit likelihood function. Maximum likelihood estimates indicate a positive though small impact of supervision on performance. However, if there is a significant and persistent increase in the level of supervision, a gain of several percentage points in the economic rate of return is predicted. Supervision is more effective early in project implementation and in projects which smaller loans. The impact of supervision appears to be primarily due to the monitoring component rather than the assistance component; however, data limitations preclude a formal test.
publishDate 2000
normalized_sort_date 2000-01-01T00:00:00Z
dc_date_str 2000
license_str protected
REPOSITORYNAME FgsRepos
REPOSBASEURL http://hades.library.villanova.edu:8088/fedora
fgs.state Active
fgs.label Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
fgs.ownerId diglibEditor
fgs.createdDate 2019-10-01T20:44:33.657Z
fgs.lastModifiedDate 2021-04-12T19:15:24.777Z
dc.title Supervision and Performance: the Case of World Bank Projects.
dc.creator Kilby, Christopher.
dc.description This dissertation explores theoretical and empirical aspects of the relation between supervision and project performance. I focus on development projects funded by the World Bank and on supervision done by the World Bank. The World Bank is the preeminent international development organization both in terms of money lent and leadership; furthermore, data measuring project performance and supervision are relative comprehensive. The link between supervision and performance is of theoretical interest because it illuminates one side of World Bank-borrower interaction and of practical interest because supervision is an instrument controlled by the World Bank which may improve project performance. Chapter One compares an adversarial view of World Bank-borrower relations with a cooperative view. The adversarial view leads to a principal-agent model where a portion of implementation problems arise because World Bank information about borrower actions is incomplete. The importance of information links the monitoring component of World Bank supervision to project performance. In contrast, asymmetric information plays no role in the cooperative view; implementation problems are purely technical and hence the role of World Bank supervision is less clear. The chapter outlines the different empirical predictions of the two views and highlights policy implications for the design and supervision of development projects. Chapter Two is an empirical study of supervision and performance which addresses issues raised in Chapter One. Data are from 1426 World Bank-funded projects completed between 1981 and 1991. Analysis of the influence of World Bank supervision on project performance uses annual supervision and annual interim performance ratings. The annual updating process which generates the discrete interim ratings is described by an ordered probit likelihood function. Maximum likelihood estimates indicate a positive though small impact of supervision on performance. However, if there is a significant and persistent increase in the level of supervision, a gain of several percentage points in the economic rate of return is predicted. Supervision is more effective early in project implementation and in projects which smaller loans. The impact of supervision appears to be primarily due to the monitoring component rather than the assistance component; however, data limitations preclude a formal test.
dc.date 2000
dc.format Villanova Faculty Authorship
dc.identifier vudl:177692
dc.source Dissertation.
dc.language en
license.mdRef http://digital.library.villanova.edu/copyright.html
agent.name Falvey Memorial Library, Villanova University
KHL
has_thumbnail false
relsext.hasModel info:fedora/vudl-system:CoreModel
info:fedora/vudl-system:CollectionModel
info:fedora/vudl-system:ResourceCollection
relsext.sortOn title
relsext.isMemberOf info:fedora/vudl:177661
relsext.sequence vudl:177661#11
_version_ 1696865883264122880
score 13.990641
subpages